Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Goliathan said in the chat room that the results 11-40 should be up soon - just be patient.

EDIT: Or, as he said, in about an hour.

Last edited by Tobias (August 20, 2011 (08:15pm))

YouTube | Twitter 

http://i1106.photobucket.com/albums/h364/sfugity/bimTMIRABbanner_zps0970ba17.png
Currently going for the "Most Inactive" BiM award.

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

sfugity wrote:

Goliathan said in the chat room that the results 11-40 should be up soon - just be patient.

He also joked this:

http://i.imgur.com/rw5IJ.png

-LASF

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Yeah but JOKED.

YouTube | Twitter 

http://i1106.photobucket.com/albums/h364/sfugity/bimTMIRABbanner_zps0970ba17.png
Currently going for the "Most Inactive" BiM award.

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

sfugity wrote:

Yeah but JOKED.

YES, IT WAS JUST A JOKE.

Whoops, Caps Lock was on. mini/XD

-LASF

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

LegoAndStickfigs wrote:
sfugity wrote:

Yeah but JOKED.

YES, IT WAS JUST A JOKE.

Whoops, Caps Lock was on. mini/XD

-LASF

You know there's a backspace button on the top right of the keyboard, right?

bricksinmotion member of the year

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

I feel the main issue with the contest was the judging. I trust Squash, and Jargon's opinion, but the other judges are relatively new members to the site, except one judge who was banned multiple times. Now you can't blame Goliathan I guess, since he never visits the site really, and doesn't know the past of the judges, and I don't expect him to run a background scan of their history's. The judging from one person was mostly based off personal vendetta against someone, giving their near perfect entry a solid 3/10 overall. This is just one example. Then the other person who is new followed the same boat as the other guy, and the third wheel didn't really know what was going on I assume, and gave a meh entry 10/10 just for lighting and prettiness. These 3 judges heavily outweigh the wise and unbiased judging of the other 2 judges. This proves judging ruined the contest. Not to be a whiny moody person, but I felt like clearing that up.

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

They should re-judge BRAWL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

https://i.imgur.com/0N0Fc4I.jpg

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

No, you really shouldn't rejudge a contest after results have been released.  Even if the original judging wasn't great (and I haven't watched the films so I have no opinion on that), it'd be really bad form to change the results after the fact.

http://i.imgur.com/wcmcdmf.png

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

The results are both final and in.

Unfortunately since the crash I've had to reenter, and a few people in the top 10 got switched around, the top 3 remain the same.

Google Docs

Last edited by Goliathan (August 20, 2011 (09:27pm))

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Congratulations to everyone! Hope to see that FoS 2011 here!!

YouTube | Twitter 

http://i1106.photobucket.com/albums/h364/sfugity/bimTMIRABbanner_zps0970ba17.png
Currently going for the "Most Inactive" BiM award.

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Didn't come in last so it's fine.

Congratulations to the top 10!

EDIT: Can you create a descussion thread for the results?

-LASF

Last edited by LASF (August 20, 2011 (09:32pm))

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

24th PLACE! So happy right now! mini/bigsmile Wait a second Goliathan... Something is wrong with the spreadsheet. All the people are in the wrong places.

Last edited by WelcomeToAwesomeness (August 20, 2011 (09:41pm))

bricksinmotion member of the year

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Oh, looks like I got sixth place and not fifth. Ah, well. Good enough I suppose. I didn't really deserve 5th in my opinion anyway.

what could have been: jeffrey and the old man make some robots
                      art page -- tumblr --youtube
              bricksinmotion's #13th best curmudgeon

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

where do I see the results? mini/tongue

I need a new name! HELP

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

Oh, seems that now I'm 16th place instead of 8th. Woop de doo.

http://i.imgur.com/WAr6hHC.png
BRAWL 2013 ENTRY Quack In Time
"Why in the world did you do a weird language if you know English?" - tenny1028

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

I'm now 7th suddenly.... wtf, Twickabrick suddenly moved to the 5th place, how is that even possible?
But Nick Durron and Stan The Lego Man definatly won, congratulated dudes!

http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t256/darkman13forever/BIMBANNER.jpg
youtube]                   Twitter]

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

18th. Okay I guess.

Goliathan wrote:

Unfortunately since the crash I've had to reenter, and a few people in the top 10 got switched around, the top 3 remain the same.

Why were they changed in places? And what do the highlighted members mean?

Last edited by Pillow (August 21, 2011 (01:16am))

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

37th place mini/sad Well, i guess its okay for a second contest. Im not good at animating though... mini/tongue iMovie hurt my quality like always mini/sad

I need a new name! HELP

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

WHAT!? I failed getting last place??? What is this

Re: BRAWL 2011 Results!

I can't complain what position I got - but seriously, this was very unorganized and messed-up. When I did FoS last year, I had every entry rated and placed before I announced the results. Also, Jstudios was robbed completely. He deserved top 5. I've watched almost every entry and his outshone most others. Also, the rating system was nuts. It was rated on 4 categories, all of which were to do solely with technicalities.  Plus, where was the theme rating? I mean, someone could have gone and just made a film with no such baring to the theme and it wouldn't matter, because it wouldn't count over technicalities. And don't get me started on execution... my main complaint is that Just Kidden's entry was miles better then Nick Durron's, and the others who placed in the top 5. His had a good plot, was nicely executed, great idea for the theme, great animation, and the list continues. I know it's done now and there's nothing more to be said, so to speak, but I feel this has to be stated. If this comes up again next year, I won't be entering, that's for sure, and I hope I can make a better decision in FoS 2.

'look like it was shot at 2 FPS by a blindfolded five year old boy with broken fingers and no thumbs.' -PushOver
I'll be back animating soon! Exams and computer faults are keeping me away </3

Drifter (THAC 11) - Here