Re: Directory Screencast

all this looks just... FORMIDABLE !

(an old unusued french word to say it is very nice).

I'm just impressed by how you can make some professionnal-looking stuff, and offer it to the bim community. Keep up the formidable stuff!

http://imgs.imagup.com/member5/1242510318_banniere_clicclac.png

Re: Directory Screencast

Coming soon?

Re: Directory Screencast

Sméagol wrote:

Well that's how it has been due to the old BF design.  The question is there for films that already have threads, as in films already posted in the forum that will be submitted to the directory, to avoid creating a second thread.  Most likely we will disable creating new threads in the Releases forum so that everything posted will automatically be submitted to the directory.  (If a film isn't completed it shouldn't be posted in the Releases forum anyway, though if a director were to make some changes retroactively, that shouldn't be a problem.)

Sounds like too much rules and standards to go by, especially if a thread has already been created prior to the directory's release.

It also sounds like you'll be preventing anyone from creating a new topic in the Release forum without going through the directory submission first.  That's fine in the future, but you're like introducing DVDs to a VHS market.  You're rendering the old threads obsolete.

Why not let those who have already posted a Release thread use that thread for their submission.  In other words, provide an option for the director to copy/paste the thread url of their film submission.

https://i.imgur.com/4b9NnS3.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/GUIl0qk.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/ox64uld.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/v3iyhE5.png

Re: Directory Screencast

I plan to add some kind of tool to link the old threads to the new films, I don't want the old threads to become obsolete. However when the directory is finished only mods will be able to post non-movie threads in the release section (for stickies, announcements etc).

Re: Directory Screencast

Yes, the plan was to allow people to integrate their previously existing threads as well, just disabling posting new threads.  This will avoid the confusion we've had in the past over submitting a film vs. posting it in the forum, it also saves the user time in the long run.

http://i.imgur.com/wcmcdmf.png

Re: Directory Screencast

SlothPaladin wrote:

I plan to add some kind of tool to link the old threads to the new films, I don't want the old threads to become obsolete. However when the directory is finished only mods will be able to post non-movie threads in the release section (for stickies, announcements etc).

What about trailers? Where would you post them? mini/confused

GET DA BOOM MICROPHONE OUT OV MA FAAAACCCEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Directory Screencast

What about people who do not wish their film to be added to the directory they just want some critique on it.

_2014

Re: Directory Screencast

SlothPaladin wrote:

I plan to add some kind of tool to link the old threads to the new films, I don't want the old threads to become obsolete. However when the directory is finished only mods will be able to post non-movie threads in the release section (for stickies, announcements etc).

That sounds like a good idea but I agree with randomparrot.  What if you don't want it submitted to the directory?

Also, if you submit your film and it gets rejected, will the forum thread still be there (if you use the forum submission thing in the addfilm).

Re: Directory Screencast

I have not forgotten about trailers, previews and films people don't want added to the directory, don't want to go into any specifics, but you will still be able to make posts like that in the Release forums.

Re: Directory Screencast

Looks good. mini/smile